Frequently Asked Questions
What is a motion for summary judgment?
- A party files a motion for summary judgment to ask the Court to decide the case (or part of it) without going to trial. In this case (regarding the CFI Waiver program), both the Plaintiffs and the Defendants have asked for a summary judgment in their favor.
- If the Court finds that important facts are in dispute, or that the law is not clear, it will say no to that request for summary judgment.
- Since both sides have asked for summary judgment in this case, the Court could grant it for one side (in full or in part) and say no to the other side (in full or in part) or deny a summary judgment for everyone.
- You can read over the requests for and against summary judgment at drcnh.org/fitzmorris-v-nhdhhs.
What happens at a summary judgment hearing?
- The hearing starts when the judge enters the courtroom. At that time, all who are able are asked to stand as the judge sits and gets settled. Then everyone sits down.
- The Court will listen to the lawyers on both sides. The Court will focus on specific legal issues for which it needs more information or has questions.
- For each specific legal issue raised during the hearing, the Court will decide if there are still disagreements about important facts, or if the law is unclear. If the Court finds that there is no dispute on the facts and the law is clear, the Court can and will make a decision without having a trial on that legal issue.
What issues will be discussed?
Both sides will be asked about the facts and the legal issues they included in their filings for summary judgment. You can read these filings at drcnh.org/fitzmorris-v-nhdhhs. The lawyers for both sides and the judge may talk about facts in the filings, but there will be no witnesses or evidence introduced at the hearing.
How can I prepare?
To better understand the legal issues in this case, visit drcnh.org/fitzmorris-v-nhdhhs. We have a plain language case summary as well as case documents and related material that you can read.
Does it matter what side of the courtroom I sit on?
No. As a visitor, you will be directed to sit in the public seating area behind the lawyers and court staff. Some accessible seating is also available.
Will I have an opportunity to speak?
No. The general public cannot speak at a hearing.
How long will the hearing last?
It is hard to determine how long a hearing will last, but we estimate that it will be at least two hours. You do NOT have to stay for the full hearing. It is better to arrive on time and leave early than to arrive late, which can be disruptive.
When will the Court rule on the summary judgment pleadings?
It often takes several months for the Court to issue decisions. We expect that the Court will issue its decision on the summary judgment requests early next year.